| |
This week's assignment:
Each team was to star and direct a "webisode"
soap opera featuring a new Soft Scrub bathroom cleaner. The best webisode as
determined by Dial Soap executives would win the task
In the boardroom
In the boardroom, Trump made it clear that he'd be sad to see anyone
from Kinetic exit, but somebody had to go. In one of the politest
boardrooms ever, nearly every negative comment was prefaced with an
expression of respect.
Ivanka probed Kristine's decision to
let Muna bully her way on camera, wondering whether it was sign of good
leadership to compromise and keep the team calm or a sign of bad
leadership to give in to a strong-willed worker.
Though no bad blood was evident, it was clear that either bad-actress
Muna or so-so PM Kristine would soon be shown the door. When Trump asked
Olympic hockey champ Angela who she'd keep on board, she begrudgingly
said Kristine. Heidi, another Trump favorite whom he described as a
"former superstar," noted that
both Kristine and Muna had made serious mistakes. Kristine erred by
leaving just as filming began, and Muna disrupted the team by being
difficult to manage.
The hot seat got even hotter for Heidi when Muna asked her point
blank who she'd choose to keep. After a lot of hemming and hawing, Heidi
finally chose Kristine over Muna. And though Trump admired Muna's bold
move of calling Heidi out, he sadly informed Muna of what she already
knew: the tactic had backfired. "You
lost this task, you did a bad job," Trump summarized.
"I have to say,
Muna, you're fired."
|
Commentary
- Prologue: James becomes Arrow's project manager with beliefs that it's either "now or never"
- Kinetic project manager: Kristine
- Arrow project manager: James
- Winning team: Arrow
- Reason for win: The team, while having a weaker story, strongly displayed the product and got the point across, according to the Dial executives.
- Reward: Team Arrow had a private flight to Sacramento and met Arnold Schwarzenegger for tea.
- Losing team: Kinetic
- Reason for loss: According to the Dial executives, even though Kinetic had a good cliffhanger, the information of the brand was not presented well. In addition, the enunciation of the dialog, particularly in Muna's case, made it difficult to understand what was going on.
- Sent to boardroom: No final boardroom.
- Fired: Muna by process of elimination. Some of Muna's acting wasn't understandable during the acting and presentation part of the task.
- Trump acknowledged that Kristine's absence during the early part of shooting and the general resulting effort of the team made the choice difficult between Kristine and Muna. Muna herself asked her teammates which of the two should they keep, both whom responded for Kristine; Trump took this advice as part of his firing decision.
Lessons Learned
- Trust, camaraderie, respect and fun are necessary for
high-performing teams.
- Last week, Arrow spent their time and attention on the negative
energy generated by a difficult personality. Now that the team is
rid of the disruptive force that was infecting them, they were able
to focus on winning with creative collaboration.
- Always take the chance to prove yourself.
- After fighting hard to stay alive last week in the
boardroom, James took Frank's advice and volunteered as project
manager this week. He said it was his chance to step up,
figuring it was a make-or-break moment. He could prove that he
deserved his chance to stay or he would lose and go home.
Because his teammates may have doubted his abilities, James
wisely chose to take a leadership role to prove his skills.
- Set priorities for your focus as the leader.
- For Kristine to leave the set to accompany Angela on a
lipstick-buying errand was ridiculous. Her focus should have been
the production. (Can anyone explain to me why it takes two women to
buy lipstick?) Leaders need to keep their eye on the big picture and
not get sidetracked micromanaging details easily delegated to
others.
- Be willing to listen.
- When James realized some of his teammates knew more than he
did about the process of making a film, he chose to rely on
their expertise. He took Nicole's advice about filming close-ups
and Tim's advice about the musical soundtrack.
- But never listen to anyone who says it can't be done.
- Arnold's pearls of empowerment wisdom: " He also noted that pain
is "temporary," but what is on film is "permanent." That seemed to
particularly motivate Nicole around wanting to work for Trump. She
may be put to the test next week when Trump reorganizes the teams
and she is pitted against her new boyfriend, Tim. In the end, there
will be only one Apprentice.
- On the other hand, don't interrupt just to hear yourself
talk.
- When Kinetic's team members were brainstorming about their
webisode, Muna questioned every idea, constantly interrupting
the flow of ideas and irritating her teammates who were
legitimately trying to envision a plan. As part of a team, work
toward the goal. Don't slow down the game.
- Don't abdicate the throne.
- As a leader, either manage a disruptive employee or risk
being managed by them. Difficult personalities are a reality of
the workplace. Effective leaders manage difficult people, or, if
they prove themselves unmanageable, reassign or get rid of them.
If you have someone who is poisoning your team, deal with him or
her. Kristine had several options with Muna. She could have taken
Muna aside and had a candid conversation while setting clear
expectations. She could have used her authority and been more
emphatic about her assessment and confidence in Muna's ability
to manage the details behind the scenes. At a minimum, she
should have screen-tested Muna's acting ability (now there's a
concept). Instead, Kristine acquiesced in her authority.
- Don't waste time.
- Yes, details are important. But on a task that has to be
turned around in such a short time, realize that there are some
elements that are more important than others. Don't bog your
team down in something that can be such a small part of the big
picture. Tim micromanaged the music bed for the webisode,
driving his teammates nuts as he spent a great deal of time on
one small piece of the soundtrack. Even if you're in charge,
check your ego at the door if there's someone who is more
knowledgeable than you are on a certain aspect of a project. It
can be risky, but in James' case, it paid off
- Be sensitive to religion in the workplace.
- When it comes to religion and deeply held personal values, being
respectful is very important. Be cautious and aware of how you
affect others with religious statements (watch out for being
perceived as overly righteous or intolerant of other's beliefs).
Muna refused to "use the Lord's name in vain" -- one of the lines in
her script. She might have approached this more diplomatically with
her teammates by noting that some audience members or their sponsor
Dial might have a problem with this scripting and then offer another
way to word it.
- Know your opponent.
- While steeling herself for the boardroom Kristine, who was
pretty sure she would have to defend herself, prepared by
reading one of Mr. Trump's books. By reading up on Mr. Trump's
philosophies and business theories, Kristine was prepared for
what was thrown at her in the boardroom. No doubt her homework
helped her remain calm and helped her keep her job.
- Be decisive.
- In her attempt to be neutral, Heidi waffled in the boardroom
when Trump questioned her about who should be fired. She is lucky he
didn't fire her for being wishy-washy. Trump isn't likely to hire
someone he deems indecisive. Leaders need to make tough decisions,
and followers want leaders who can make decisions. There are few
things in the workplace more frustrating than trying to follow
someone who can't make a decision!
|
|
© 1998-2007 Maureen
Moriarty/Seattle Post-Intelligencer |
| The Report Card |
Kinetic:
- Effort --
- Performance --
- Creativity --
|
|
|
Arrow:
- Effort --
- Performance --
- Creativity --
|
|
|
|
|
|