| a dubious fifteen minutes of fame | an index |
|
a tissue
the stephen r. glass index |
| "The
only unusual thing about Stephen Glass' fall from grace, as far as I can
see, is that he was caught. Fabrication, in small or large part, will always
be common in a profession that, too often, values sensation over substance,
and where older editors increasingly turn to younger writers to provide them
with "buzz", or a window on trends, real or spurious. Freelance writers and
junior editorial staff, like Glass, are the disposable shock troops of this
regrettable but seemingly ineradicable side of the business."
-Rick McGinnis |
|
| This index of the work of former New Republic associate editor Stephen Glass might be useful to those interested in his meteoric rise and fall as a freelance public affairs journalist. This is as complete an index of his published work as can be compiled.
|
|
part one: the paper trail |

| Articles with known, possible, or obvious
fabrications are marked with ***.
Most of Glass' work has been taken down, but the few links here were active
as of 05/14/03.
- December 25, 1995 - "Cheese Biz". - January 6 & 13, 1997 - "Probable Claus".
*** - January 19, 1998 - "Washington Diarist:
State of Nature" -column.*** The New Republic printed a short summary of Glass' fabrications in their June 29, 1998 issue. The magazine has also purged most of Glass' work from their website. Click here to go to their website.) |
| - Fall 1994, #70 - "Yes We Kenosha". - Winter 1995, #71 - "A Pension Deficit Disorder". - Spring 1995, #72 - "Hire Education". - Summer 1995, #73 - "Happy Meals". - January-February 1997, # 81 - "Who Needs the SBA?". - May/June 1997, #83 - "Mrs.Colehill Thanks God for Private Social Security". *** |

| - February 1998 - "Prophets and Losses". ***(WBEZ's show "This American Life" interviewed Glass about this piece. It is available on RealAudio as part of a radio documentary called "How to Take Money from Strangers".) |
| - July 1997 - "The Bounty Hunter". - December 1997 - "The Hollywood Hustle". - February 1998 - "Cashing in on Credibility". - April 1998 - "The Vernon Question".*** The late editor John F. Kennedy Jr. drafted an apology to Vernon Jordan for this last article. George is now defunct. |
| - October 16, 1997 - "The College Rankings
Scam". RS #771 - March 5, 1998 - "Truth + D.A.R.E.". RS #781 - April 16, 1998 - "Case History: Kellie Ann Mann", "Case History: Todd Davidson", & "Case History: Douglas Lamar Gray". Sidebars to "Mandatory Minimums: A National Disgrace" by William Greider. RS #784 - May 28, 1998 - "Eric Smara". RS#787 |

| - A search of the last year's worth of NYT Magazines reveals no byline by Glass, though apparently he had submitted an article just before he was fired by The New Republic. |
| - January 4, 1997 - "Amazon.Con - 'Earth's Biggest Bookstore'? Pshaw. Cheaper, faster, and more convenient? Pshaw again." with Jonathan Chait |
.
![]()
| - 3/12/97- "Market Features: Book Review: The Online Investor" |
.
part two: the reaction |
.
| American Journalism Review: - "Shattered Glass at The New Republic" By Lori Robertson (June 16-22, 1998) The Boston Globe: The Boston Phoenix: Brill's Content: City Paper (Pittsburgh): CNN Online: Columbia Journalism Review: Daily Pennsylvanian: Earth Times: Eye Magazine (Toronto): FEED: Forbes Digital Tool: Fox News: George: Los Angeles Times: Memphis Flyer: Mother Jones Online: The New Republic: Newsweek: The New Yorker: New York Observer: New York Post: The New York Times: Online Journalism Review: El Pais (Madrid): Pennsylvania Gazette: Phillymag (Philadelphia): Reed Magazine: Salon: Slate: The Spectator (U.K.): Suck: TIME: The Times (London): U.S. News & World Report: Vanity Fair: Washington City Paper: Washington Post: Wired News: - - -
|
THE GLASS BOOK: Simon and Schuster published a novel by Stephen Glass - The Fabulist - the story of a young reporter named Stephen Glass whose career as a journalist is built on lies. Here's an excerpt from the novel. Here's the amazon.com page where you can buy a copy. To publicize the book Glass did an interview with "60 Minutes" - here's a transcript of that interview, and here's Virginia Heffernan's Slate review of Glass' TV appearance.
|
part three: lies, and damned lies |
.
| 2005 Diana Griego Erwin, a former columnist for the Sacramento Bee, is under investigation after the paper cannot verify 43 sources she used in a sampling from her 12 years of work for the paper. From a Guardian (UK) story: "Griego Erwin, who has said her resignation was for personal reasons, joined the Bee after a distinguished career at other newspapers. She worked on a project that won a Pulitzer Prize at the Denver Post in 1986 and also won a George Polk award and the 1990 commentary prize from the American Society of Newspaper Editors. "The discrepancies in Griego Erwin's work were discovered after the Bee tightened its anonymous sources policy and questioned whether columnists were given too much latitude." 2003 Perfectly timed for the release of the Glass book and movie, Jayson Blair, a New York Times reporter, was fired from the paper in May for fabricating sources and plagiarizing quotes from unattributed sources. Here's the Times' explanation of how Blair pulled off his deceit, and here's an annotated list of articles by Blair. The scandal has forced the resignation of Times editor Howell Raines. Here's Jack Shafer's Slate analysis of the scandal, written before Raines' resignation, which is full of other useful links. 2002 Christopher Newton, an Associated Press reporter, was fired on Sept. 16th "after the agency received inquiries about a Sept. 8th story about U.S. crime statistics." AP reviewed the hundreds of stories Newton wrote for the agency and found quotations in 39 separate pieces from sources that could not be located. Newton, an AP reporter since 1994, wrote on a wide range of topics, "ranging from the war in Afghanistan to science, mental health, and education." Michael Finkel, a succesful freelancer, allegedly made up the principle character in his Nov. 18th, 2001 feature for the New York Times Magazine. In his piece, "Is Youssouf Male a Slave?", Finkel apparently created a composite character from several interview subjects, going so far as to falsely identify a young man photographed for the piece as his protagonist. Once a contributing editor at the NY Times Magazine, Finkel has been fired for the falsification. Inquiries are going on at other magazines as to other possible fictions. Finkel has written features for Atlantic Monthly, Sports Illustrated, Outside, Skiing and National Geographic Adventure, and is the author of a book. Here's Howard Kurtz in the Washington Post on Finkel. Here's the editor's note from the Times. Here's a piece from Canada on the Finkel affair. 2001 Tom Junod and Esquire magazine have admitted that a profile of REM singer Michael Stipe that ran in the June 2001 issue was substantially fictionalized. While they claim that the fabrication was implied in a subheadline, and provided a website with an annotated version of the piece, they were unapologetic. "The story as it is written in the magazine is what I thought about him distilled into fiction," Junod said. "I think Michael Stipe comes alive in the fictional section." Esquire Editor-in-chief David Granger added: "In the first place, one of our duties is to amuse and entertain our audience." In one bold move, a once-respectable magazine has erased the line between journalism and fan fiction. Columnist Patricia Smith of the Boston Globe resigned from the paper after it was discovered that she had made up quotes and sources. Click here to read her mea culpa, here for the Globe's Ombudsman's review of Smith's case, and here to read an report on the incident by the Globe. Here are a couple of letters from sympathetic readers of Smith's column. Here are reports from the Washington Post, Fox News, CNN,The Oregonian and Salon. 2000 and Before In 1981, Washington Post reporter Janet Cooke won the Pulitzer Prize for "Jimmy's World", the story of an 8-year old heroin addict. Two days later Cooke admitted that Jimmy did not exist, and Post editor Ben Bradlee returned the award. Investigations revealed that Cooke had also made up her stellar credentials. Humiliated, Cooke lost her job, but later re-emerged selling her story to Hollywood. Over twenty years ago, veteran journalist Nik Cohn wrote "Tribal Rites Of The New Saturday Night" for New York magazine, an article that inspired the movie "Saturday Night Fever". Years later, he admitted to New York that he had made up the majority of the piece. Click here for a summary of this incident. At the Cincinatti Enquirer, reporter Mike Gallagher was fired for stealing voice mail messages in the course of writing a piece on the Chiquita Banana company, aided, it seems, by an employee of the company. The Enquirer has run an apology to the company on its front page. Gallagher's primary crime is that he assured his paper that his sources were obtained in a legal manner. Salon has an essay about why this might be the most important media crisis of the year. Both CNN and Time magazine reported that the United States had used nerve gas in an attack on Laos during the Vietnam War in an attempt to kill defectors. They based their evidence on the recovered memories of veterans of Operation Tailwind.; They were forced to retract the stories when their sources complained that they had been misquoted. Here's a really good essay from Salon on CNN, Time, and the crisis in media credibility, from the perspective of a former Time investigative reporter. Lies and hoaxes have plagued journalism since its birth, perpetrated intentionally or not by a cast ranging from Edgar Allen Poe and H.L. Mencken to Seymour Hersh and Pierre Salinger. Click here for a useful overview of these media deceptions. The best source for media gossip and news is probably Jim Romaniesko's
Media News blog.
|
"caveat lector, caveat editor" |
| Lies, Damn Lies, and Fiction | Shattered Glass | The Fabulist |